Chris the Fermenter

Basic Pizza Sauce

This recipes is intended as a starting place for dialing in your pizza sauce. It is intentionally vague because I really believe you should make the sauce to your personal taste preferences. Some brands of tomatoes will need more salt than others. Slowly dial in your salt amount until you get it to where you like it, and remember that cheese will bring saltiness to the pizza as well.

Ingredients

IngredientAmount
Crushed/Ground Tomatoes28 oz Can
Minced/Pressed Garlic1 Clove
Basil2 Whole Leaves
Extra Virgin Olive OilA Splash / To Taste
SaltTo Taste

Ingredient Considerations

Tomatoes

Here are some brands of tomatoes that I enjoy, most of them are easy to obtain online or in a local Italian food store:

  • Bianco DiNapoli Organic Crushed Tomatoes
  • Sclafani Crushed Tomatoes (From NJ, not Italy)
  • Stanislaus 7/11 Ground Tomatoes (No, they don't sell these at 7/11 😉)
  • Jersey Fresh Crushed Tomatoes

Instructions

Add all ingredients to a bowl or container and mix well, do not blend. Season with salt to taste. This sauce is best if made at least one day in advance. It can be kept sealed in the fridge for up to 2 weeks.

Variations

Depending on the pizza you are making you may want to try some variations, for example:

  • For NY pizza, try adding some dried oregano.
  • For Sicilan pies, add some tomato paste.
  • For a Grandma pie, add some finely minced anchovies.
  • For extra umami, add grated Pecorino and anchovies.
© 2023 Chris Main